
This is my first post here in a while because I’ve mostly been dropping thoughts on Substack, where I have virtually no following, so that makes a lot of sense. But also I seem to use that platform to mostly be a bit miserable & whingy I guess.
Today I want to start off by apologizing to my Jewish readers, of which there are a fair few on Substack, as I will in part be discussing historical events in Jewish history through a Christian lens, which I have learned is offensive to some of you at worst & sort of cute & silly to many more. You are very welcome to comment/correct my understanding of your history below. I think you will be in good company with everyone else, who will also be offended by this.
If you’re Catholic, today is the 25th Sunday in ordinary time of year C, which means we read Amos 8:4-7, Psalm 113, St. Paul’s 1st Letter to Timothy 2:1-8, & Luke 16:1-13. Taken in their entirety, these readings are both an indictment of the societies of the time (spanning many hundreds of years) & also a call for grace, even for idiots (be they rulers or just ourselves).
That is of course a trite, one sentence summary of two thousand years of scholarship & debate, as Luke 16:1-13 in particular throws people for a loop, even priests. Father preached on it one way (& I argued with him about it after Mass), & several other homilies I’ve listened to this weekend also have their interpretations of this gospel that, incidentally, appears to have established the very first collection agency.
I’ll try to break down the essential meaning of the readings as a whole so that we can have any kind of discussion about it in the following paragraphs.
- Humans are very preoccupied with their own wealth & comfort, to the point where they eschew holy days that not only give glory to G-d (Amos is a Jewish text), but also respite to the poor.
- God is above all nations, is his own nation, & the poor are citizens of it, therefore he exalts them above all.
- We need to pray for people in charge, because if they’re at peace, so are we.
- If you can be shrewd in dumb but complex human things, why can’t you handle God’s really simple request, which is to just put him first? From that, all good things follow.
Cue the atheists screaming that you don’t need a deity to be good. And guess what? I don’t disagree, as your perception of deity is limited & I too would be pretty pissed off if someone told me, “You have to be good because Jeff said so.” Well, who the hell is Jeff & why do I care what he thinks?
But God isn’t some guy called Jeff. God is love. This is a polite & tidy abstraction, but it is also true. If God is love, putting God first means all your actions have to be rooted in love, even if the poor disgust you, even if leaders are the actual worst, even if people online are horrific.
And this comes to my awful AI picture above: Who would Jesus, who is both God & man (& therefore love), overthrow?
First, you may wonder why I am using the word “overthrow”. It is because of you, the internet. The swarm of angry locusts that is Most People on the Internet is, depending on who is president/premiere/prime minister, absolutely convinced the only way to Fix Everything™️ is to overthrow the current ruling party. Voting isn’t enough (though it is clear many of you have not tried it), campaigning isn’t enough, we need to make incendiary low info memes & scream at each other on camera & storm buildings & do graffiti & light things on fire & shoot people because the memes we saw convinced us they were bad people (this is commentary on the last several publicly discussed murders, not any particular one. Many have online indoctrination in common).
Let me tell you a story (Jews, here is a good place to pop in & go “Well, actually…).
At the time of Jesus’ birth, Israel was occupied by Rome. It was tense, to say the least. Rome “allowed” the Jews to have their own client king (during Christ’s time, there were a couple of Herods), & they also got a Roman prefect. The Jews, who had been occupied & even exiled by numerous outside forces for the past few hundred years, were both desperate to keep their identity & customs as well as the peace. The religious leaders knew that they walked a fine line with the Romans, & were keen to downplay any perceived rebellion lest the people suffer.
Then Jesus came. Now keep in mind, as Christians understand it, the Jews were waiting on a messiah to specifically overthrow the Romans & re-establish the Kingdom of David. Jesus was not an insurrectionist. He healed the sick, raised the dead, & if you don’t believe any of that, he preached leading an authentic life of service based in love rather than a showy, ritualistic adherence to tradition (the irony of saying this as a Catholic is not lost on me, but we can explore that later).
The Jewish leaders of the time were not after Jesus because he was sneaking into centurion’s homes at night & lighting them on fire. In fact, Jesus was doing something entirely more dangerous. He was repeatedly proving that there is a far higher authority on Earth than Caesar. He was showing it as well as saying it. He was proving it by loving people that others ignored or outright hated. He forgave the absolute worst people in their society. He healed a centurion’s servant & tapped a tax collector (they worked for the despised Romans) for his entourage. Jesus rejected no one, chastised people who abused their power, & loved indiscriminately, including awful people in power.
Jesus was messy.
The Jewish leadership at the time were not wrong; if the Romans started being agitated by the way people responded to this Jesus guy, they’d all be enslaved/killed/etc. They also had absolutely no inkling that he could possibly be the messiah. Where was his army? What was this total nonsense about loving your enemy?
So we killed God in his human form. We all did, because that incident is not a point in time so much as it is a point in the sphere of existence. We can see if from all angles. From it all things branch, & to it all things go. Every time we choose hate, ignorance, indifference, every time we make an idol of our own feelings instead of recognizing them as a response to a stimulus, we are killing love. We are murdering hope.
So.
How did that work out for the Romans?
Without lifting even a finger, let alone a sword, Jesus overthrew the Roman empire in 300ish years. By 380, Christianity was the official state religion of the Roman Empire, which again is not exactly what Jesus was going for, but we humans are only shrewd in dishonest wealth, & we don’t know how to do things correctly. We are like children playing dress up in our parents clothes, which are far too big for us, & sometimes we trip in those adult shoes as we clomp around. We are mimicking as we best know how.
Unfortunately, by then the Jews who had not morphed into Christians by then were being persecuted in new ways, which never ended, & Rachel continues to weep for her children.
The point is (I always have one) that rage, hatred, feeling offended & put out, misrepresenting our opponents’ views with low info memes, & killing people is not how Jesus overthrows anyone. Love doesn’t do any of that. Love also doesn’t sit around & let people be hated, made into low info memes, & killed. Love says, “Thankfully, this scary meme/post you’ve shared is incorrect. Isn’t THAT a relief!” And maybe share some facts instead if you can. Failing that, as you will be piled on, report such things as false info. In person is much easier, usually, because you can have a discussion, there isn’t an anonymous audience of potential millions weighing in, & you can modulate your tone & facial expressions.
Nobody’s mind is changed with vitriol.
The poor (which you can interpret to be anyone who lacks privilege across the board) are the victims of all of this. You losing your mind online or even just being petty isn’t helping one injured, sick, unhoused, or war torn person. Your protests filled with angry slogans aren’t lifting up anyone. Our culture now equates condemnation of one group as the lifting up of another. No political party or creed is immune to this right now. Most people cannot assert their own position without demonizing the other, & that is because issues are so much more complex that you honestly don’t have the time or energy to do even cursory research on the info behind the meme or TikTok that got you so worked up. And then the algorithm sends you more, & you do not even question if there is another perspective. The algorithm becomes all. It has your full attention. You find a community based on the algorithm. You become part of the algorithm.
And not one suffering person is helped by any of this. You are made to feel like you are part of something & doing something super important without doing anything more than providing ad revenue for a corporation while simultaneously contributing to the indoctrination of vulnerable populations prone to violence.
it is very okay & normal to feel weird right about here
And you can stop it. Breathe deeply & read the following things. You can be of any or no faith to do so:
- I like social media & I want to use it. I don’t want it to use me.
- I do want to help people who are suffering, but I am currently powerless to do so, & I hate this feeling.
- I can use the internet to find ways I can put on my own oxygen mask, then help others. Part of the reason I am so eager to share memes & blog posts that agree with my own ideas is because I myself am suffering & want to feel understood.
- Once I feel secure in myself & my thoughts 75% of the time, I can meaningfully find ways to contribute to the authentic & caring society in which I want to live. Meanwhile, I can always participate in small acts of kindness when it is safe for me to do so.
- If you are a Christian, you can add, “Who would Christ destroy in a debate?” Only correct answer: religious leaders. Get owned, religious leaders!
But seriously—more love, more seeking to understand, less reacting & seeking to dominate. Now go outside. Or at least put the phone down & read a book.









